Consultant

The Union has genuine fears that loss of this valued feed source could  have a knock on effect on Scotland’s already declining cattle and sheep  population.
Membership concerns stem from the fact that at a significant number of  Scottish distilleries and associated sites, incineration or anaerobic  digestion plants are in place or are planned. These use, or will use  products from the distilling process to generate energy rather than be  available as a valued livestock feed.
Last week, NFU Scotland Chief Executive Scott Walker met with members of  Banff and Buchan Branch – in the heart of the Speyside whisky industry –  to discuss the issue.
Commenting Mr Walker said: “Scotland may be sleepwalking towards a  fundamental change in the availability of animal protein, with negative  consequences for the livestock and dairy sectors of Scottish  agriculture.
“With some incineration and anaerobic digestion plants already  operational and many others at different stages of development, many  farmers are concerned that we could be naively generating a feed issue  for the livestock industry that could result in livestock numbers being  reduced.
“Last week’s branch meeting further underlined the farming community’s  concerns regarding the medium and long-term availability of co-products  from distilleries, due to the proliferation of such energy generating  plants replacing the traditional units that produce dark grains from  draff and pot ale.
“The development of plants which burn or process co-products to generate  energy appears to be largely driven by the distillers need to reduce  their annual CO2 emissions.   While this may coincide with one Scottish  Government target, it jeopardises another, which is to grow the food and  drink sector.
“We believe there is a strong need to evaluate how these developments  will impact on the availability of draff and dark grains in both  geographically local markets and across the whole of Scotland.   Such an  analysis will help to identify the potential impact that there could be  on the livestock sector and help inform the need for any mitigation  action.
“In addition to an analysis on the future availability of co-products  that come from the distilleries, we strongly believe that an independent  analysis of the reduction in CO2 emissions that it is claimed will  actually be achieved by replacing a dark grain plant with an  incineration plant.    
“Government and industry needs to reassure themselves that the  proliferation of incineration and anaerobic digestion plants are not  simply a means of the distilleries ticking a box on carbon emission  reduction targets but exporting the problem to somewhere else.”






















